As an example, the essayists compare Socrates' dismissive dialogue with the out-of-touch religious leader Euthyphro over the meaning of piety with a "Daily Show" snippet in which Stewart mocks Alaska Sen. Ted Stevens' uninformed speech about the proposed Net Neutrality Act.
After a clip in which Stevens shows little knowledge about the Web, Stewart pounces: "You don't seem to know jack ... about computers or the Internet. But hey, that's OK; you're just the guy in charge of regulating it, so what difference does it make?"
Philosopher? I'm not sure. Journalist? Maybe. Looking at the 10 elements of journalism, as stated by Bill Kovach and Tom Rosensteil, Stewart might just be as ethical as the "real" journalists of major newspapers across the United States.
1. Obligation to truth. In a satirical, hilarious way, Stewart does lead the viewers to his version of truth.
2. Loyalty to citizens. Yes - Stewart is definitely loyal to his audience, showing them the injustices of the world.
3. Discipline of verification. Not really. Here Stewart falls short, his satirical comments often have a factual basis, but it's up to the audience to research further on the topic. However, that's more than what I can say for many of today's journalists, as an LA Times reporter was accused of fabricating a story about Brett Farve's potential return to the NFL.
4. Maintain independence. Stewart makes fun of the people that make his "news." Independent? I say yes.
5. Independent monitor of power. In his own satirical, humorous way, I'd say yes. He often sheds light on ridiculous happenings in government, such as the oil mongrels talk with Congress.
6. Provide a public forum. With a large following and a community on Comedy Central's website, I'd agree.
7. Make the significant interesting and relevant. By mocking and satirizing public figures and events, his audience rolls with laughter. Yes, yes, yes.
8. Comprehensive and proportional. Not really, he's obviously left-leaning. However, by adding Colbert to the mix with his own right-leaning show, there's an attempt to show both sides.
9. Personal conscience. I have no idea. Jon Stewart, do you exercise personal conscience with what you decide to put on the show?
10. Rights and responsibilities of citizens. I watch the Jon Stewart Show and often look up topics he addressed to get the rest of the story. Do you?
No comments:
Post a Comment